Captain America’s Bicentennial Battles / Marvel Treasury Special #NN - Jack Kirby art & cover, Kirby / Barry Windsor Smith art
Jack Kirby |
- - - - - - - - - -
Kirby cover pencils (Frank Giacoia inks) = **
Kirby inside front cover pencils (Frank Giacoia inks) = ***
Kirby story pencils 77 pages / Smith inks (10 pages), John Romita, Herb Trimpe remaining inks = ****
Kirby inside back cover pencils (Frank Giacoia inks) = ***
Kirby pencils (Frank Giacoia inks) 3 pin-up pages = **
Kirby back cover pencils (Frank Giacoia inks) = ****
Jack Kirby / Barry Windsor Smith |
Home / Kirby / Smith / Marvel Treasury Special / Captain America / Marvel
ebay >this issue >Kirby >Smith
(The affiliate links above earn commissions which help support this blog)
Captain America’s Bicentennial Battles / Marvel Treasury Special #NN - Jack Kirby art & cover, Kirby / Barry Windsor Smith art
Reviewed by Ted F
on
3:02 PM
Rating:
2 comments:
You are so right about the Kirby/Smith collaboration. Smith lent Kirby's art a lush realism without taking away from the penciler's dynamism.
Herb Trimpe and John Romita also did an admirable job inking, but Smith's contribution was just so much more impactful. The change from page 10 to 11 was jarring for me when I first purchased it, and probably for many other fans as well. Another combination I would have liked to see more of was Kirby inked by Neal Adams. They collaborated on some Jimmy Olsen covers in the early 1970s and a Destroyer Duck cover in the early 1980s. You would think their contrasting styles would clash, but the end results were quite beautiful.
Post a Comment